Is Tithing Biblical?

Saturday, March 29, 2008

Recently CBS Sunday Morning news devoted a segment to the question of whether the Bible teaches tithing. The reporter featured a new book entitled "Should the Church Teach Tithing?" As a whole, the program had a decidedly negative overtone when it came to the biblical practice of stewardship we call "tithing."

Most of the arguments were gathered around a few predictable stack-poles.
1) Church leaders have used verses taken out of context.
2) Pastors have abused the teaching of the tithe to manipulate people to give.
3) The practice of a weekly collection is of relatively recent origin.
4) Tithing is a part of a legal system while believers are under grace.
5) Certain televangelists have used the tithe to fund their own extravagant lifestyle.

What are we to say about such objections?

The program was brief and thus only sound bites of much larger arguments were broadcast, but it is worth our time to look at these general objections. Let's look at a primary New Testament text where Jesus mentions tithing -- Matthew 23:23. The context is a denunciation of the scribes (experts in the Law) and the Pharisees (legalists).

Jesus brings seven specific charges, each beginning with the phrase "Woe to you ..."
Following the introduction there is a brief cameo illustrating their failure to live up to the claim to be guardians of the Law. The fourth woe involves tithing as taught in the Old Testament Law. As might be expected, the first century legalists had been meticulous in observing the law. They had tithed their garden herbs. But Jesus charged that they had neglected the weightier matters of justice, mercy, and faith -- echoing the summary of true religion given by Micah (6:8). Jesus insists -- "These ought ye to have done, and not to leave the other undone." This passage is not that difficult to understand in its present context. The mastery of elementary matters such as tithing is no excuse to ignore weightier issues. Nonetheless, it is obvious that Jesus believed and taught that tithing was a fundamental aspect of true faith.

We must confess that some on occasions have used biblical texts related to tithing in a manipulative manner for reasons that are not spiritually ethical. Such behavior is improper, but it does not alter the basic biblical teaching. We should clearly teach that the stewardship of one's entire life is an act of worship and devotion. Tithing should not be connected to subscribing to a budget, nor should it be presented as a means of receiving financial favor from God.

The historical argument cited in the broadcast was based on the need of the church to receive weekly offerings when the church was no longer funded by the state. I would insist that the church should never have been funded by the government in the first place and that a better historical marker would be the early church, not relatively recent history. Recent history contains numerous examples of misunderstanding and misapplication of biblical teaching, but that fact does not alter basic biblical teaching. The church should always examine its teaching based on biblical truth, not historical tradition.

The issue of tithing being a matter of the law in a community defined by grace misses the mark on several points.

First, the tithe preceded the giving of the Law. The first mention of tithing is found in Genesis 14:20 where Abram gives Melchizedek a tenth of all he had. Abram has defeated Chedorlaomer and thus is entitled to the spoils taken in battle. The contrast in the story is telling. The defeated king of Sodom wants to make a deal with Abram, allowing him to keep the goods and returning the people to him. Melchizedek, on the other hand, meets Abram on his return and provides for his needs, bringing him bread and wine. Abram's spontaneous gift of the tithe is based on his renewed understanding that "the most high GOD " is the possessor of the heavens and the earth. This is a biblical truth that goes back to the beginning chapters of Genesis. The spontaneous act of tithing was later codified in the Law.

Second, grace does not negate the Law but rather fills it full of meaning. If one looks at Jesus' treatment of various Old Testament Laws in the Sermon on the Mount, we will find that He always exceeds the Law by internalizing and intensifying it. For example, one might outwardly obey the Law about murder but yet express intense anger toward his brother.

Now in the kingdom instituted by grace, this person stands guilty (Matt. 5:21-22). By the way, Jesus actually mentions the practice of giving in this same context. He indicates that when you come to present an offering and you remember that your brother has something against you, you should go and be reconciled to your brother. But that is not the end of one's duty under grace. He must "then come and offer thy gift" (5:24). It would be a disgrace to grace to indicate that the person who has received grace would do less than one under the Law.

How do we answer the objection that "some televangelists" have manipulated their hearers and used the tithe to fund an extravagant lifestyle? We must always stand against any and every abuse of spiritual authority. But the fact that some abuse their office does not provide an excuse for us to ignore the teaching of Scripture.

We could point to "charlatans" in any and every profession. We might, for example, discover that a medical doctor has used his profession to fund an extravagant lifestyle.
First, that doesn't mean that most doctors are doing the same. Second, it doesn't mean that we should ignore principles taught by legitimate physicians. But having said that, church leaders should be rigorous about good stewardship of all the funds over which they have responsibility. For example, Paul gives a detailed description of those who will be delivering the offering intended for the saints in Jerusalem (2 Corinthians 8:16-24). Church leaders must practice stewardship with absolute integrity. After all, everything belongs to the King, and is intended to advance His kingdom and to bring glory to Him alone. We are privileged to participate in His service here on earth and we will be privileged to serve him through-out all eternity.

But "tithing" is not the entire story. The Bible teaches the stewardship of all of one's life -- time, talents and treasurers. We serve a King who has equipped us to effectively serve Him and has thus enabled us to live daily in such a manner that we can lay up treasures in heaven. We should not be content to argue about the amount of the tithe; rather we should develop a faithful lifestyle that will enable us to give ourselves completely as a "living sacrifice" to our King. To do so means that we will have to deal with issues such as our spending habits and unbiblical debt. It should be stated that God is concerned about how we manage all of the resources that He has placed at our disposal. So don't become a modern-day Pharisee and believe that the tithe exempts you from "the weightier matters of the law." But then on the other hand, don't ignore that Jesus clearly said about the giving of the tithe, "these ought ye to have done".